Definitions
Several terms must be defined as we begin our
description of a comparative file review:
DISCRIMINATION RISK: the risk that similarly situated
applicants receive different outcomes on a prohibited bas
FOCAL POINT: any combination of loan product, decision
center, prohibited basis group, control group, time period,
and credit decisioning process (underwriting or terms and
conditions)
PROHIBITED-BASIS1 GROUP: that group of applicants who
may have been treated less favorably in relation to the
institution’s underwriting or terms and conditions criteria o
lending practices followed in the credit decisioning proces
CONTROL GROUP: that group of applicants who may have
been treated more favorably in relation to the institution’s
underwriting, terms and conditions criteria, or lending
practices followed in the credit decisioning process
SIMILARLY SITUATED APPLICANTS: those nonprohibited
basis applicants who share some of the creditworthiness
factors that an institution considers in making credit
decisions—credit scores, debt-to-income ratios, credit
histories, or other factors—with applicants who fall into on
or more prohibited-basis groups
MARGINAL APPLICANTS: prohibited-basis group and con
group applicants who are neither clearly qualified nor clea
unqualified
BENCHMARK APPLICANTS: in an underwriting review, the
most-qualified prohibited-basis group applicants who were
denied credit
OVERLAP APPLICANT: in an underwriting review, those
approved control group applicants who are no more or les
qualified than benchmark applicants
REASON FOR DENIAL: the reason(s) included on the adve
action notice provided to a denied applicant
UNDERWRITING CRITERIA: those criteria that an institutio
uses in determining which applicants to approve and whic
applicants to deny
TERMS AND CONDITIONS CRITERIA: those criteria the
institution uses in determining such aspects as price, closing
fees, maturity, collateral, and escrows to offer an approved
applicant
EXAMINATION TYPE: the type of examination used in
relation to the focal point being reviewed
What Is a
COMP
File
BY PHILLIP R. FREER, JR., CRCM,
AND CALVIN R. HAGINS, CRCM